Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
×



Details

Submitted on
July 15, 2010
Image Size
10.7 KB
Resolution
111×71
Link
Thumb
Embed

Stats

Views
15,299
Favourites
691 (who?)
Comments
154
Downloads
23
×
Twilight vs Harry Potter by Starrphyre Twilight vs Harry Potter by Starrphyre
I'm really tired of people saying Twilight is the new Harry Potter.

It isn't true and Twilight gets bashed for it.

Harry Potter
Coming of Age
Plot Driven
Twilight
Romance
Character Driven

Both Fantasy-ish

Both are new, original ideas that took risks and it payed off, THAT'S IT



the correlation is the fans of Harry Potter grew up with the books and then (mostly the girls) moved from kids literature to young adult. (I'm not saying Harry isn't for adults because we've all been kids once)


Apples and Oranges, both fruit completely different

and last comment from me
people who hate Twilight, don't see it for what it is
Add a Comment:
 
:iconchaoticdarkangel:
Some people are saying Twilight even copied off of Harry Potter. I've read all the books for both series and seen all the movies, they are completely and totally different so how people can say one copied off the other I'll never understand O_O
Reply
:iconkonri-kari:
See, I completely agree. I don't understand why people hate on Twilight so much. The movies were pretty bad, but the books were awesome! I like both, and don't see why people feel you must choose between the two.
Reply
:iconnewsuperdannyzx:
oh shut up the books are basically boring too with poor made characters and poorly shitty plots
Reply
:iconkonri-kari:
I depends entirely on what you like. I mean, I haven't read them a bunch, but they are better than some books out there. They aren't the best books in the world, but they aren't the worst either.
Reply
:iconnewsuperdannyzx:
oh yeah a mary sue named bella with boyfriends are so boring with most god awful shitty plots even i wants burned the book for that
Reply
:iconkonri-kari:
If you hate Twilight so much, how did you wind up here (on this piece)?
Reply
:iconnewsuperdannyzx:
because i dont likes how people kept on saying twilight is new harry potter which it bullshit
Reply
:iconkonri-kari:
And I completely agree with you. They are nothing alike, and anyone who says they are needs his or her head examined. However, just because some people who read them are idiots, it doesn't necessarily mean that the books themselves are bad. Nothing can replace Harry Potter.
Reply
:iconnewsuperdannyzx:
Yeah i thinks books are bad for having very boring characters like bella or plots are just unmade sense at everything
Reply
(2 Replies)
:iconthylacine333:
I found them to be a completely different genres. Twilight is romance, Harry Potter is ameld of a lot of different genres (action, fantasy, romance. etc)
Reply
Add a Comment: